Writing Placement Prompt — Spring 2019
Please read “In Defense of the Vegan Hot Dog” by Emily Dreyfuss. Then, draft and compose an argument summary. An argument summary articulates the author’s central claim and explains how she uses evidence to explore and develop it. Imagine that you are writing to someone who has not read Dreyfuss's article but who would be interested in her argument.
Keep in mind as you draft and compose that you will include neither your own argument nor your opinions about Dreyfuss's ideas. Your task is to identify Dreyfuss's claim accurately, to summarize the key evidence she uses to develop it, and to emphasize the relationship between her evidence and her argument. Please do not quote more than a short phrase or two from the article, and do your best to avoid close paraphrases.
It’s a good idea to use your introduction to introduce the author and the subject of her article, and to explain fully what you consider to be the fundamental or the most significant argument. You cannot summarize every example that Dreyfuss uses in her article, so carefully select evidence from the text to include in your summary.
As you write, keep in mind that summaries should:
- Begin with a title that reflects the authors’ main argument.
- Make explicit the author’s central claim.
- Have unified and coherent paragraphs.
- Contain relevant and detailed support from the text.
- Your completed draft should be about 500 words.
- Do not include your name on the argument summary itself.
- Your completed draft is due no later than 11:59 p.m. EST on Wednesday, Jan. 2, 2019.
- Do not wait until the last day to write your first draft; leave some time to revise and carefully edit your draft, and submit as polished of a final draft as you can.
- We ask that you complete this assignment on your own, without seeking assistance from others.
- Please do not do any research for this assignment, or any reading beyond the article provided to you.
- If the Writing Program believes you are ready to start with English 102, we will make the schedule change for you and notify you via email.
- Please do not purchase your textbooks until you have received the results of the writing placement evaluation. The textbooks for English 101 and English 102 will likely be different.